
Description:
Walnut comb is the result of having both the pea-comb (P) and rose-comb (R) genes. The combination creates a broad, low comb with a bumpy walnut-like surface. It is a gene interaction, not a separate walnut mutation. (1, 2)
Both loci are dominant. Pea comb involves SOX5 on chromosome 1 and rose comb involves MNR2 on chromosome 7. Birds need a dominant allele at both loci to express the walnut form. (1, 2)
In 1905, Bateson and Punnett used rose and pea combs to show how two separate factors could produce the walnut comb. Their crosses also gave the famous 9:3:3:1 split of walnut, rose, pea and single-combed offspring, one of the early practical demonstrations of Mendelian genetics in chickens. (3)
For breeding, the important part is that walnut is made from two separate dominant traits, not one walnut allele. A bird can carry Pea without Rose, Rose without Pea, or both. If you cross a walnut bird to a single-combed bird, the chicks may have several comb types depending on which alleles the walnut parent carries. (1, 2)
Breeding with Walnut Comb: If two birds are PpRr, the basic two-locus expectation is 9 walnut : 3 pea : 3 rose : 1 single. That is the historical cross, not a promise for every walnut-combed pair. A walnut PpRr crossed to a single-combed pprr bird should give roughly one-quarter of each comb type, assuming independent assortment and normal viability. (1, 3)
The most useful test is to separate the two comb genes in a breeding plan. A Silkie with a walnut comb may be P/P R/R, P/p R/R, P/P R/r, or P/p R/r, and all four can look similar. Crossing to a truly single-combed bird will expose some of those differences in the first generation; watching the second generation is even more revealing. A smaller, smoother walnut is also part of breed selection, so shape alone does not tell you whether both loci are fixed. (1, 2)
References & Further Reading
1. Imsland et al. (2012). The Rose-comb Mutation in Chickens Constitutes a Structural Rearrangement Causing Both Altered Comb Morphology and Defective Sperm Motility. PLOS Genetics. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pgen.1002775
2. Fulton, J. E., McCarron, A. M., Mullen, A., Ali, L., and Tarrant, K. J. (2025). A review of genetic variation underlying chicken phenotypic diversity. Poultry Science 104:105761. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.psj.2025.105761
3. Bateson, W., and Punnett, R. C. (1905). Experimental studies in the physiology of heredity: Poultry. Reports to the Evolution Committee of the Royal Society 2:99–119. The classic two-locus comb crosses, summarized by OMIA. https://omia.org/key_articles/landmarks/

